Hillmeyer v. Watz

OPINION

PARKER, Judge.

This case arises from Paul Hillmeyer’s allegation that he mistakenly settled a disputed claim with Nicholas Watz by paying *90$11,827.50 to satisfy an uncovered, $20,000 check issued to satisfy a debt that existed between Watz and Patrick Delare. Hill-meyer alleged the check was a forgery, but settled the claim nonetheless. Watz moved for summary judgment and asserted the affirmative defense of accord and satisfaction. The trial court granted the motion, holding there was no genuine issue of material fact in dispute. We reverse.

FACTS

Paul Hillmeyer, a farmer in Cokato,…