Sheppard v. Old Heritage Mutual Insurance

Memorandum Opinion by

President Judge Crumlish,

This original jurisdiction action, brought by the Pennsylvania Department of Insurance in its capacity as liquidator of the Old Heritage Mutual Insurance Company (Old Heritage), seeks the surrender of certain books and records, property, stock certificates and assets of Old Heritage, Gibraltar Life Insurance Company (Gibraltar) and Pennsylvania Health Insurance Agency (Pennsylvania Health).

The present matter is an encore presentation by the parties stemming from our recent decision in Sheppard v. Old Heritage Mutual Insurance Co., 45 Pa.…