Deep South Oil Company of Texas v. Federal Power Commission

(dissenting).*

Again, my differences, while substantial are basic and, in this approach, as before, Magnolia Petroleum Co. v. Federal Power Commission, 5 Cir., 236 F.2d 785, at pages 793 to 811, I accept the Court’s fair and faithful outline of the cases. Since these cases1 present the *890common problem of jurisdiction of the Federal Power Commission over the first sale by an oil-gas-well producer made before production or gathering has ended, I treat them together despite minor variations in factual details.

Likewise, it both simplifies and emphasizes the nature of this problem to concentrate…