Kapiolani Estate, Ltd. v. Atcherley

*455OPINION OP

The material facts in this case are precisely the same as those before this court and before the supreme court of the United States in the Lewers & Cooke case reported in 18 Haw. 625, 19 Haw. 47 and 222 U. S. 285. The only fact contended by the appellee to be before this court in the case at bar and not to have been before the supreme court of the United States in the Lewers & Goohe case is that Kinimaka was the guardian of Kalakaua at the time that the claim for the land was presented to the Land Commission. In addition to the fact noted in the majority opinion that the…