Legal Opinion · Dissent

Chandler v. Hospital Authority of Huntsville

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided September 5, 1986No. 84-1297Published

1Dissent

I concur in that portion of the opinion which holds that, with respect to Chandler's contract claim for the wrongful death of her son, the holding in Geohagan v. General MotorsCorp., 291 Ala. 167, 279 So.2d 436 (1973), is controlling.

As to the other holding, I must respectfully dissent from the majority opinion on these grounds:(1) The equal protection claim was not adequately presented in the trial court, and there was no showing made that the legislature did not have a rational basis for granting immunity to this particular hospital.(2) This Court has previously decided that hospitals…

2Cases cited24 opinions

  1. Alabama State Federation of Labor v. McAdorySupreme Court of Alabama · 1944
  2. Jackson v. City of FlorenceSupreme Court of Alabama · 1975
  3. Hutchinson v. Board of Trustees of University of AlabamaSupreme Court of Alabama · 1971
  4. Geohagan v. General Motors Corp.Supreme Court of Alabama · 1973
  5. Home Indem. Co. v. AndersSupreme Court of Alabama · 1984

19 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API