American Homeland Title Agency v. Stephen Robertson

Sykes, Circuit Judge.

During a random audit, the Indiana Department of Insurance ("the Department") discovered that American Homeland Title Agency had committed hundreds of regulatory violations. After several rounds of negotiation, American Homeland agreed to pay a fine and relinquish its licenses. But just a few months later, American Homeland sued the Department's commissioner, Stephen Robertson, for allegedly discriminating against the company because of its out-of-state residency.

We need not reach the merits of that discrimination claim. In its agreement with the Department, American…