BRETTER v. PEYTON

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA BETH ANN BRETTER and : JAMES R. PEYTON, JR., : Plaintiffs, : : CIVIL ACTION v. : No. 22-2509 : KAREN F. PEYTON, : Defendant. : McHUGH, J. June 6, 2023 MEMORANDUM Plaintiffs in this inheritance dispute between siblings move to compel the Defendant’s state and federal income tax returns spanning the past decade. Plaintiffs claim that they need to access these records to trace the full extent to which Defendant financially benefitted from the assets she allegedly mishandled. Defendant objects on the basis that the…