George O. Naugle v. John J. O'connell, Harris Combs and Paul R. Dean, Trustees, United Mine Workers of America Health and Retirement Fund

STEPHEN H. ANDERSON, Circuit Judge.

This case comes to us on appeal from district court judgments upholding the denial to plaintiff/appellant George O. Nau-gle of pension benefits from the United Mine Workers of America 1950 Pension Plan (“the Plan”), and ordering Naugle to restore to the Plan trust $6,902.89 plus interest that the trust had already paid him. For the reasons set forth below we affirm the judgments of the district court.

I

To be eligible for Plan pension benefits, the Plan requires an employee to satisfy any one of three different vesting options. First, an employee may qualify…