Murphy v. English

This is an action upon an account annexed, wherein the plaintiff claims the defendant owes him the sum of $5,268.76 for insurance premiums.

The defendant in his answer denied that he owed the plaintiff the stated sum, and further stated that the plaintiff had intentionally over-charged the defendant by manipulating figures on statements supplied to the defendant and had added insurance that the defendant never had contracted for.

The trial judge found for the plaintiff in the sum of $1500.00.

■ At the conclusion of the trial, the plaintiff filed requests for rulings of law, which were acted upon…