Sunray Oil Corporation v. G. T. Allbritton

While I concur fully in the order overruling the motion for rehearing, in view of the statement in appellant’s motion that the failure of the Court to state its views on the issue of the claimed excessiveness of the verdict has left them in doubt as to their proper course, I have concluded to briefly state my own views.

1. The action of the district judge in refusing to relieve against the verdict as excessive is, unreviewable by this court if the verdict is excessive only in fact, reviewable if it is excessive in law.

2 Whether, in the opinion of the district judge, a verdict is excessive as…