Legal Opinion · Dissent

Hamburger v. Economy Department Store

South Dakota Supreme Court

Decided December 31, 1928No. File No. 5746Published

1DissentBrown, J.

The vacillating attitude with respect to the crucial question in this case, from which the court seemed to have freed itself by the decision in Qualseth v. Thompson, 44 S. D. 190, 183 N. W. 116, followed in Adams v. Morehead, 45 S. D. 216, 186 N. W. 830, appears to be reverted to by the decision in the present case.

In Hagen v. Townsend, 27 S. D. 457, 131 N. W. 512, where plaintiff claimed to have sold wheat at a price amounting to $385.38, while defendant claimed the amount to be $360.20, and sent plaintiff a check for the amount, which plaintiff indorsed and cashed, this court said: “There…

2Cases cited5 opinions

  1. Morgan v. Hannah's LesseeTennessee Supreme Court · 1849
  2. Qualseth v. ThompsonSouth Dakota Supreme Court · 1921
  3. Adams v. MoreheadSouth Dakota Supreme Court · 1922
  4. Hagen v. Townsend & WhiteSouth Dakota Supreme Court · 1911
  5. Siegele v. Des Moines Mut. Hail Ins.South Dakota Supreme Court · 1911

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API