In Re GVR Ltd. Co., Inc.

BISTLINE, Justice,

specially concurring.

This case is in a way a companion to In re New Concept Realty, 107 Idaho 711, 692 P.2d 355 (Sup.Ct.1984), another certified question from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals involving there the validity of acknowledgments.

There, in a special concurrence, I was a sole vote for the overruling of Harris v. Reed, 21 Idaho 364, 121 P. 780 (1912). It was the United States district judge’s reliance on that case which led to his decision which turned out to be contrary to this Court’s unanimous contrary perception of Idaho law. In my special concurrence I doubted…