United States v. Hall

I concur that the military judge erred in refusing to admit the testimony of A1C Gilbert concerning whether SrA Stachum asked appellant to provide him with steroids. A1C Gilbert would have testified that he overheard SrA Stachum ask appellant if he could “hook him up.” Such testimony should have been admitted to impeach the testimony of SrA Stachum that he never asked appellant to provide him with steroids.

In addition, A1C Gilbert should have been permitted to testify that appellant complained to A1C Gilbert that SrA Stachum kept bugging appellant about obtaining steroids. A1C Gilbert’s…