Gandia v. Porto Rico Fertilizer Co.

ANDERSON, Circuit Judge.

This is the same case in which this court rendered an opinion on June 21, 1923, 291 F. 18. We then held the Supreme Court of Porto Rico in error in reversing the District Court of San Juan, for lack of necessary parties, in order to determine title to 60 shares of stock of the defendant company. After mandate from this court, Gandia contended that the reversal involved the merits, and thus affirmed the decision of the District Court in his favor. The Fertilizer Company contended that this court decided only the question of law as to necessary parties, and that the…