Arkansas Valley Ry., Inc. v. United States

I agree with what Judge Whitaker has written with regard to the awarding of an “in place” value for two sections of the railroad.

I do not agree with that part of the decision of the Court which awards compensation to the plaintiff computed at prices which could not have been lawfully asked or paid in a sale of the property at the time of the Government’s requisition.

This case does not involve any necessity on the part of the plaintiff to replace the property taken, which was the equitable basis on which this Court’s decision in the case of John J. Felin and Co., Inc., v. United States, Ct.…