Legal Opinion · Dissent

City of San Antonio v. Tenorio ex rel. Tenorio

Texas Supreme Court

Decided March 23, 2018No. 16–0356Published

1DissentJustice Guzman

Dogmatic adherence to language divorced from context can distort the law. This axiom has long guided our interpretation of statutes,1 and it applies with equal force when we construe precedent. Application of precedent requires us to consider *781not only the language an opinion employs, but also the animating logic.2 In this case, which involves the Texas Tort Claims Act's actual-notice exception, the Court's cramped construction of Cathey v. Booth3 and its progeny thwarts, rather than effectuates, legislative intent. By construing the actual-notice exception to require self-acknowledgment of…

2Cases cited89 opinions

  1. City of Keller v. WilsonTexas Supreme Court · 2005
  2. Texas Department of Parks & Wildlife v. MirandaTexas Supreme Court · 2004
  3. Lehmann v. Har-Con Corp.Texas Supreme Court · 2001
  4. Payne v. TennesseeSupreme Court of the United States · 1991
  5. Transportation Insurance Co. v. MorielTexas Supreme Court · 1994

84 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API