Frank Gillis, M.D. v. Joey Frazier, as of the Estate of Florine Bryant

*1135MURDOCK, Justice

(dissenting as to case no. 1121205 and concurring specially as to case no. 1120292).

I. Case No. 1121205:

Dr. Gillis’s Rule 60(b), Ala. R. Civ. P., Motion

Dr. Gillis filed a motion seeking relief under Rule 60(b)(6), Ala. R. Civ. P., from the liability aspect of the trial court’s judgment on the ground that a juror had prior knowledge of, and a bias against, Dr. Gillis not disclosed by her during voir dire. I respectfully disagree with the reasons voiced in Part II.A. of the main opinion for rejecting what I consider to be Dr. Gillis’s compelling position on this issue.6

The main…