New York Temporary State Commission on Lobbying v. Simmons

*750OPINION OF THE COURT

Bernard J. Malone, Jr., J.

This is an application by the New York State Temporary Commission on Lobbying to enforce subpoenas issued by the Commission to the defendants. On consent, the parties have resolved all of the issues that were before the court except the question of whether defendant Dr. Benjamin Chavis is required to turn over to the Commission his personal expense accounts from January 1, 20031 to the present. That demand is item five in the two subpoenas addressed to Dr. Chavis. The application of the Commission for an order pursuant to CPLR 2308 compelling Dr.…