Legal Opinion · Dissent

Thomas's administrator v. United States

United States Court of Claims

Decided December 15, 1879Published

On the claimant's Motion. The Reporters’ statement of tbe case: Tbe former decisions of tbe court in this case will be found in 11 O. Gis. K-, 722j 12 ib. 273. Tbe following are tbe words of tbe present motion: “ Motion to amend petition, die.

Read the full summary

On the claimant's Motion. The Reporters’ statement of tbe case: Tbe former decisions of tbe court in this case will be found in 11 O. Gis. K-, 722j 12 ib. 273. Tbe following are tbe words of tbe present motion: “ Motion to amend petition, die. “Mary W. Thomas’ administrator, ) W. Calvin Wells, Uo. 3400. vs. f “The United States. \ “Whereas tbe said Mary W. Thomas was, at tbe time of tbe commencement of this suit, tbe sole executrix of tbe last will ■& testament of John H. Thomas, deee’ed, late a citizen of the United States, residing in Yazoo County, in the State of Mississippi, & was also…

1Dissent

Drake, Ch. J'.,

dissenting:

I cannot concur in the action of the majority of the court on this motion, and will state the grounds of my dissent.

In doing so, I shall treat the matter as if, besides the motion to amend the petition now passed upon, there' were before us, also, a motion to substitute the administrator of John H. Thomas as claimant; for, upon the allowance of the present motion, the case is put in the position of the administrator of Mary W. Thomas suing to recover a claim in favor of John H. Thomas. The motion for substitution must therefore necessarily follow .and be allowed.

Were…

2Cases cited22 opinions

  1. United States v. GillisSupreme Court of the United States · 1877
  2. Lessee of Sicard v. DavisSupreme Court of the United States · 1832
  3. Barnes v. . QuigleyNew York Court of Appeals · 1874
  4. Haynes v. MorganMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · 1807
  5. Kiphart v. BrennemenIndiana Supreme Court · 1865

17 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API