Dunlap v. Hinkle

McHUGH, Chief Justice:

This action is before this Court upon the appeal of Gary A. Dunlap, Ernest L. Isen-hart, Jr., Daniel T. Christian and John M. Butcher, the appellants, from an order of the Circuit Court of Upshur County wherein that court dismissed a civil action filed by the appellants against Robert E. Hinkle, the appellee. The appellants had commenced the civil action against the appellee in an effort to enforce a mechanic’s lien they had filed against the appellee’s real estate. This Court has before it the petition for appeal, all matters of record and the briefs of counsel.

In…