Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn.

I dissent.

Article I, section 1 of the California Constitution declares a right of privacy. Its pronouncement is express. Nothing is left to implication. “All people” have an “inalienable right[]” to “pursu[e] and obtain[]” “privacy.”

Before proceeding a sentence further, we must make one point pellucidly clear.

This is not a case about the “policy” this court may think it best to formulate and implement with regard to privacy.

Rather, it is a case about the California Constitution and the role of the judiciary within the order it establishes.

The majority all but abrogate the right of privacy.…