City of Newark v. Civil Service Commission

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Perskie, J.

This writ seeks to review the action of the civil service commission in setting aside the dismissal of the respondent Samuel J. Goddiess as a patrolman of the police department of the city of Newark and ordering his reinstatement.

Again it becomes necessary to point out that the record submitted does not contain a judgment, which should set out a statement of the evidence upon which it is based. Freudenreich v. Mayor, &c., Fairview, 114 N. J. L. 290; 176 Atl. Rep. 162, and cases therein cited. And there is doubt whether the transcript of the…