Cuzzupe v. NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INSURANCE GROUP

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA KELSEY CUZZUPE, CIVIL ACTION Plaintiff, v. NO. 25-8-KSM NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INSURANCE GROUP, Defendant. MEMORANDUM MARSTON, J. April 9, 2025 In insurance contracts, as in life, you get what you pay for. Plaintiff Kelsey Cuzzupe took out an automobile insurance policy through Defendant New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Group (“NJM”). In exchange for lower premiums, Cuzzupe agreed that NJM would not cover noneconomic damages from car accidents involving an underinsured motor vehicle unless her injuries fell under…