Cline v. Butts

B. E. Cline brought an action against Dr. J. IT. Elays for injuries alleged to have occurred to B. E. Cline from a water pitcher falling from the third story of an office building and hitting B. E. Cline on the right shoulder, and causing adhesions of the muscles of the shoulder, great bodily pain and suffering, and permanent injury.

Dr. J. H. Hays occupied two rooms, as lessee, on the east side and near the southeast corner of the third story of a building in Enid. On the south, the windows were open and a hallway led into the office of Dr. Hays, and made an air passage into and through Dr.…