Columbia Insurance v. Baker

ORDER

ROY, District Judge.

This case is a declaratory judgment action arising from a single vehicle automobile accident. The operator of the vehicle was using same with the permission of, and for the benefit of, its owner. In cross-motions for summary judgment, both the insurer of the driver, plaintiff Columbia Insurance Company, and the insurer of the truck’s owner, JEtna Casualty and Surety Company, seek declarations that no coverages exist under their respective polices with their respective insureds. For the reasons set out below, the Court grants both motions.

I. The Facts

Separate defendant…