Dole v. Lublin

The single ground of appeal is the action of the trial court in setting aside the verdicts given to the plaintiffs by the jury. The court’s memorandum shows that the ground upon which this action was taken was the view that the jury could not reasonably and properly have found otherwise than that the cause of the accident was the negligence of the plaintiff’s driver and that the defendant’s driver was not negligent.

From the evidence the jury could reasonably have found that the plaintiff in the first mentioned case is a son of the plaintiff in the second case, and was then a boy about eight…