Seffens v. Carisch

As answer to the third question of the special verdict the jury found that Carisch was acting as the agent of Mrs. McKenney in withholding-the certificate. The court- set aside the answer of the jury to this question upon *152the ground that there was no credible evidence to sustain such answer. We have carefully reviewed the evidence and are satisfied that the action of the court was fully warranted. Carisch was the husband of Mrs. McKenney’s daughter. No unpleasant relations existed between McKen-ney and Carisch. McKenney haid arrived at the age of seventy-seven years, and it is natural to…