Julius Hyman & Co. v. American Motorists Insurance

CHRISTENSON, District Judge.

This is an action for recovery on a certain boiler and machinery insurance policy issued to the plaintiff by the defendant. It is claimed by the plaintiff that within the terms of the policy accidental damage occurred to a pipe in a Dowtherm Boiler, which forced a shutdown of the boiler and resulted in the partial interruption of plaintiff’s business. A substantial loss under the policy is claimed.

The particular question now before the Court arises on plaintiff’s motion for the production, inspection and copying of a certain report prepared by Mr. C. R. McGraw…