Parbilla v. Velarde

COOPER, District Judge.

Having reached a conclusion that petitioner is entitled to the relief requested, I think it appropriate that I state briefly the grounds on which I base my decision. The defendants by their answer to the petition allege that plaintiff is not physically capable of performing the duties of a police guard and they also allege that plaintiff’s employment with the Insular Police Force was a temporary one.

Before taking up the facts with respect to the physical condition of petitioner I should like to make it clear that the decision of the Police Commission, based on the…