AMERICAN NATURAL RESOURCES, LLC v. EAGLE ROCK ENERGY PARTNERS, L.P.

TAYLOR, J.,

{1 The questions before this Court are whether a clause in an agreement giving a liinited liability company the right to participate in all future wells on unleased property violates Article II, Section 32 of the OKla-homa Constitution prohibiting perpetuities and whether a limited lability company is a life in being for purposes of Article II, Seetion 32 of the Oklahoma Constitution.' We answer the first question in the affirmative and the second question in the negative. We find that the district court did not commit error in granting a motion to dismiss based on these two…