Legal Opinion · Dissent

Jahncke Service, Inc. v. Fertel Corp.

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided January 20, 1970No. 49854Published

1DissentBarham, Justice

I am unable to determine whether the majority’s judgment is founded upon guaranty, suretyship, contract to purchase, or some other contract imposing a primary obligation upon defendant Fertel to pay for materials purchased by another. Guaranty and suretyship may not be proved by parol evidence, and the written instrument relied upon fails to establish these obligations. No one can seriously argue that the record supports a finding of a contract of purchase between Jahncke and Fertel. Any other contractual relationship establishing a primary obligation would require the plaintiff to prove all…

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. Jahncke Service, Inc. v. Fertel, Inc.Louisiana Court of Appeal · 1969

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API