In re the Arbitration between Bobak & AIG Claims Services, Inc.

I concur with the conclusion of my colleagues that the interest of judicial economy is served by deeming the factual findings made by Supreme Court in the order *1105entered upon remittal in Matter of New Hampshire Ins. Co. (Bobak) (72 AD3d 1647 [2010]) to be applicable to this appeal. I further concur with the conclusion of my colleagues that petitioner’s contention that the court erred in failing to join Travelers Insurance Company (Travelers) and Ohio Insurance Guaranty Association as necessary parties is not properly before us.

I disagree, however, with the conclusion of my colleagues that…