Application of Jacob G. Braun

RICH, Judge.

This appeal is from the decision of the Patent Office Board of Appeals, one board member dissenting with opinion, affirming the examiner’s rejection of appellant’s application, Serial No. D-39,-249, filed December 9, 1955, for “Ornamental Iron Work.”

The rejection was based on unpatentability over the prior art as shown by a single reference, Sweet’s Architectural File, 1954, Section 5e, sub-section Fi, page 5, design 75. This page is a collec*739tion of illustrations of products of the J. W. Fiske Iron Works which are of the type used on house fronts and porches to frame doorways and…