Marine Holdings, LLC v. N.Y.C. Comm'n on Human Rights

GARCIA, J. (dissenting).

***1048Petitioners proved that the requested accommodation-converting a window to a door and installing a ramp-would create an undue hardship. Nothing in the record-certainly no "substantial evidence"-supports the New York City Commission on Human Rights' conclusion to the contrary. Accordingly, I dissent and would affirm the order of the Appellate Division.

Petitioners' tenant is unable to enter or leave her apartment without being carried. She asked petitioners to install a wheelchair-accessible entrance to her unit, and contacted the Commission. Two Commission…