Campbell v. Shaw

DISSENTING OPINION OF

FREAR, J.

I respectfully dissent and in stating my reasons I shall refer only to the three main points involved in the case, all of which *123are closely related, and upon one of which the other members of the Court base their decision and upon another of which they express different views. It will be unnecessary for me to express an opinion upon the other points raised by counsel. The three points referred to are (1) the $2,000 exemption or the discrimination between incomes over and under $2,000, (2) the partial exemption of incomes under $4,000, or the discrimination…