In re Chalmers

Hasbrouck, J. (dissenting).

Charles B. Chalmers, receiver of the Second Avenue Railroad Company of New York, has filed a petition with the Public Service Commission of the State to require the Interborough Rapid Transit Company and New Fork Railways Corporation to furnish him electrical service at a just and reasonable charge and complaining that the rates charged the petitioner are unjust and unreasonable. The Commission dismissed the petition upon the ground of lack of jurisdiction. The case comes here upon an order of certiorari. All parties agree that the single question presented for…