Watson v. York Metal & Alloys Co.

DISSENTING OPINION

Bland, Judge:

The manifest intention of Congress to afford adequate protection for all kinds of tungsten and tungsten material is so strongly indicated by the manner in which the subject is treated at so much length, and with such care, in the steel schedule, that, in my judgment, it should not be ignored unless no other reasonable interpretation of the language used can be indulged.

The incongruous result arrived at by the majority opinion, which places a duty of 75 cents per ton upon imported material, which, according to the declared purpose of Congress, should bear not far…