Bonneville v. City of Alpena

{dissenting). On September 30, 1907, the plaintiff, a physician, in the city of Alpena, at about the hour of 7:30 p. m., was driving at an ordinary gait along Chisholm street, one of the principal paved streets of the defendant municipality. One Bertrand was the owner of premises on the easterly side of Chisholm street. He desired to connect his premises with the sewer in Chisholm street, which lies under the westerly edge of the pavement. For this purpose he employed one Maynard, a plumber. A few days before the happening of the accident Maynard applied to William Stout, defendant’s street…