Grimaldi v. Local No. 9

Dissenting Opinion by

Mr. Justice McBride:

The Journeymen Barbers, Hairdressers, Cosmetologists and Proprietors’1 International Union op America consists of local unions and employers’ guilds whose membership comprises barbers, hairdressers, wavers, marcellers, cosmeticians, manicurists, masseurs and proprietors (Article I, Section 1). In respect of barbers there are three classes: proprietor barbers,2 *17journeymen barbers,3 and employer barbers.4 Proprietor barbel's and journeymen barbers (which are the two classes material here) are both eligible to join the union.5

Local No. 9 is a local of the…