Legal Opinion · Concurrence

True v. Utah Department of Transportation

Court of Appeals of Utah

Decided May 10, 2018No. 20160704-CAPublished

1Concurrence

HARRIS, Judge (concurring):

¶ 50 I share my colleagues' view that the district court correctly entered summary judgment in UDOT's favor, and therefore agree that the district court's judgment should be affirmed. However, I reach that conclusion for different reasons. In my view, the Trues properly preserved for appellate review the issue of whether UDOT is immune from suit pursuant to the Utah Governmental Immunity Act's (the Act) "permit exception," and we ought to reach the merits of that issue. On the merits, however, UDOT has the better of the arguments. I would therefore affirm on the…

2Cases cited17 opinions

  1. State v. JohnsonUtah Supreme Court · 2017
  2. Patterson v. PattersonUtah Supreme Court · 2011
  3. State v. GarciaUtah Supreme Court · 2017
  4. Bagley v. BagleyUtah Supreme Court · 2016
  5. Gressman v. StateUtah Supreme Court · 2013

12 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API