WEST v. McKeon

Dissenting Opinion

Gilkison, J.

I dissent to the majority opinion in this case for the following reasons:

First.

The only assignment of error in the appeal, omitting caption and signature, is as follows:

“Now come respondents-appellants, by E. J. Wiltrout, John D. Knodell and Robert F. Hanley, their attorneys, and assign as error the final order of the Superior Court of Lake County sitting at Gary, Indiana, in the above entitled cause, in so far as that order:

“1. Discharged the petitioner-appellee from restraint, detention and custody of the respondents-appellants; and

“2. Refused to grant…