Vogts v. Guerrette

MR). Justice Frantz

dissenting:

Candor requires the admission that appellate courts of a number of states have held Guest Statutes not violative of some of the constitutional provisions cited in the proceedings of this case. But, in my humble opinion, these courts have not, as intimated in the majority opinion, resolved all or satisfactorily the serious problems presented to us for determination. In those decisions relied upon by the majority, constitutional safeguards apparently were , fed to the capacious maw of police power, as if rights guaranteed by a written constitution must succumb to…