Maria Mendoza, Individually and on Behalf of Stephen Mendoza, a Minor Theresa Trujillo, Individually and on Behalf of Albert Trujillo, Joe Trujillo, and David Trujillo, Minors Alberto Sanchez, Individually and on Behalf of Jaime Sanchez, Ana Celis Sanchez, John Sanchez, Ernest Sanchez, George Sanchez, and Betty Sanchez, Minors and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, and Julia O. Flores, Billie Gutierrez, Theresa Medina, Betty M. Granillo, Carol Cruz-Popkin, Barney Paul Popkin, Carmen P. Urrutia, Manuel Alvarado, Carolyn Hackworth, Gloria Hagler, Johnny Randolph-Kelly, Thelma B. Manriquez, Aldolfo A. Suarez, Nat Washington Ii, Ralph O. Gomez, Juan Brito, Marcia Almeda, Emilia Talamantez, Ellen Lee Esperanza Silva, Antonette Romo, Ronald Q. Huerta, and Lupe Montano, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellants v. United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number 1 the Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry, Individually and as Members, Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Thomas Lee, Individually and as Superintendent of Tucson School District Number 1

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit