In the Matter of Petition for Naturalization of Richard John Longstaff

The majority has certainly reached a logical conclusion, based upon its intelligent analysis of applicable legislation and jurisprudential authority, that the petitioner Longstaff may be denied naturalization in 1983 because, when he was admitted to the United States in 1965 (following which he has led a constructive life), he was a homosexual and thus could have been excluded from admission to the United States. The majority therefore concludes that Longstaff was not “lawfully admitted” to the United States, a prerequisite for naturalization.

I respectfully dissent. For the reasons…