Gulledge v. Wester

In this negligent nuisance case, Clear Lake Shores residents, Robert and Diana Gulledge, were permanently enjoined from finishing construction of a second-story deck on their boathouse after their neighbors complained that the tall structure would block their water views. The Gulledges appeal, contending that the evidence is legally and factually insufficient to support the negligent nuisance claim and the issued injunction. Alternatively, they argue that the injunction is broader than the pleadings and evidence permitted.

We reverse and render.

*811Background

Roughly a dozen homes are located on…