Legal Opinion · Dissent

V-1 Oil Company v. Lacy

Idaho Supreme Court

Decided February 23, 1976No. 11798Published

1DissentMcFADDEN, Justice

The basis of the majority opinion is simply that appellant is without any administrative remedies and hence could bring his action for declaratory judgment in district court. It is my conclusion that this determination is incorrect, and the summary judgment should be affirmed.

In the first place, the majority opinion recites that “respondent then made what he labeled an 'arbitrary assessment’ for 1973 by multiplying the 1972 valuation of appellant’s personal property by a penalty factor of three.” Nowhere in the record does it appear that respondent Lacy ever denominated his assessment a…

2Cases cited5 opinions

  1. Grever v. Idaho Telephone CompanyIdaho Supreme Court · 1972
  2. Washburn-Wilson Seed Co. v. Jerome CountyIdaho Supreme Court · 1943
  3. Franden v. JonassonIdaho Supreme Court · 1973
  4. In Re Felton's PetitionIdaho Supreme Court · 1957
  5. Bengoechea v. Elmore CountyIdaho Supreme Court · 1913

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API