Churella v. Pioneer State Mutual Insurance

Plaintiffs Mark Churella, Susan Radtke, and Peter Treboldi appeal as of right the trial court’s order dismissing their suit pursuant to MCR 2.116(C)(8) for failure to state a claim on which relief may be granted. This case arose when plaintiffs brought suit to compel defendant Pioneer State Mutual Insurance Company and its directors, defendants Dan Czmer, Jack D’Arcy, Harlan Gingrich, Robert West, Carleton Wilson, Dale Little, Milton Timmerman, and Gordon Gingrich, to distribute the company’s excess surplus. Plaintiffs claimed a right to sue as policyholders and therefore owners of Pioneer.…