Bivin v. Southern Oil Service, Inc.

Plaintiff has appealed from a judgment in favor of defendant, entered on a verdict directed at the conclusion of proof. The assignments, which are numerous, fall in three general categories: (1) Whether plaintiff made out a case of liability; (2) whether the court erred in excluding certain evidence plaintiff offered; (3) whether the court erred in admitting certain evidence over plaintiff’s objection.

We have concluded (1) that plaintiff did not make out a case of liability; (2) that the evidence excluded would not have done this if admitted; (3) that any error committed in admitting evidence…