Legal Opinion · Dissent

Estella Robinson v. City of Bluefield

West Virginia Supreme Court

Decided October 31, 2014No. 13-0936Separate

1DissentLoughry, Justice

In complete disregard of the unfortunate truth that not all dogs are like the beloved Lassie, a vicious dog has been granted a pardon by the highest court of this State. Indeed, the majority of this Court has seemingly turned a blind eye to the fact that the dog in question1 broke free of its chain and engaged in a brutal and unprovoked attack upon an experienced humane officer,2 whose resultant injuries required surgery and a hospitalization that approximated five days.3 The majority also seems to disregard the fact that the dog’s owner pled guilty to owning and keeping an animal known by…

2Cases cited12 opinions

  1. Martin v. Randolph County Board of EducationWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1995
  2. Vest v. CobbWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1953
  3. State Ex Rel. Frazier v. MeadowsWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1994
  4. State v. CollinsSupreme Court of South Carolina · 2014
  5. Sawh v. City of Lino LakesSupreme Court of Minnesota · 2012

7 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API