Shuman v. Winnick

Bernard Shuman filed a complaint for declaratory judgment in the trial court. The complaint alleged that, after Mr. Shuman entered into a contract to purchase real estate from Annette, Steven, Todd, and Dana Winnick (the Winnicks), a dispute arose regarding the description of the property. The trial court ruled in favor of the Winnicks and Mr. Shuman appeals, contending the trial court abused its discretion in ruling against him. We disagree and affirm.

Mr. Shuman leased Filthy McNasty’s Bar and a nearby residence from the Winnicks. When he expressed an interest to purchase the property, the…